My JTAGICE mkII was behaving flakey due, I think, to the ribbon cable connection to the target connector (the emulator seemed to stabilize if I wiggled this end of the ribbon cable). Finally, though, it stopped altogether, with none of its LEDs lighting up (I confirmed power to the target connector, but can't easily trace it farther back than that). I've re-seated the ribbon cable at both ends into its little surface mount connector, but no luck.
So, I'm faced with
1. Trying to get this one repaired (is that even possible?).
2. Buying a new one.
3. Buying a JTAGICE 3 (2/3 the price of the mkII).
4. Buying an AVR ONE!, on sale for the same $199 as the JTAGICE 3.
I'm strictly 8-bit for the foreseeable future, so I don't think I would benefit from most of the distinguishing features of the AVR ONE! My current boards are Xmega with 6-pin .1" headers for PDI.
Advice?