Forum Menu




 


Log in Problems?
New User? Sign Up!
AVR Freaks Forum Index

Post new topic   Reply to topic
View previous topic Printable version Log in to check your private messages View next topic
Author Message
bobgardner
PostPosted: Feb 19, 2012 - 10:21 PM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Sep 04, 2002
Posts: 23495
Location: Orlando Florida

Anyone been following Andrea Rossi's E-CAT progress? He has some hydrogen and some nickel powder and a 'secret catalyst' and he heats it up with a KW or so, and after an hour, he unplugs it and it keeps putting out a couple KW for a couple hours. The traditional physicists all think its snake oil because they cant figure it out, but A Dr Zawodny at NASA thinks its something. It sure would shake up the balance of cash flow from North America to North Africa. Note that this message has hints of science, physics, economics, but hopefully, no politics.

_________________
Imagecraft compiler user
 
 View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
zbaird
PostPosted: Feb 19, 2012 - 11:37 PM
Raving lunatic


Joined: Aug 13, 2006
Posts: 7279
Location: Bellingham, WA - USA

Quote:
The traditional physicists all think its snake oil because they cant figure it out

The history of science is strewn with examples of arrogance finally having to give way to paradigm shifting breakthroughs. Not to say that by far most snake oil isn't just... snake oil.

_________________
Chuck Baird
"I understand with a sigh and a duh"
-- Smiley
http://www.cbaird.org
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
bobgardner
PostPosted: Feb 19, 2012 - 11:45 PM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Sep 04, 2002
Posts: 23495
Location: Orlando Florida

One guy that observed the demo said it was putting out 2.5KW for an hour after they shut off the input, and no one could figure out how to get that amount of power using a chemical reaction. There was an amp clamp on the hot wire from the ac plug, but the skeptic said they were bootlegging in the extra watts up the third wire ground. After it runs for a while, they find copper mixed in with the nickel. Like the hydrogen nucleus jumped into the nickel nucleus and made some copper and releaed a bunch of heat. I understand ohms law, but this seems a lot farther out than that. Transmuting metals. Lead into Gold. Alchemy. Philosopher's Stone.

_________________
Imagecraft compiler user
 
 View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
js
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 12:06 AM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Mar 28, 2001
Posts: 22243
Location: Sydney, Australia (Gum trees, Koalas and Kangaroos, No Edelweiss)

Wouldn't trust Italians myself....

_________________
John Samperi
Ampertronics Pty. Ltd.
www.ampertronics.com.au
* Electronic Design * Custom Products * Contract Assembly
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
zbaird
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 12:13 AM
Raving lunatic


Joined: Aug 13, 2006
Posts: 7279
Location: Bellingham, WA - USA

Quote:
Wouldn't trust Italians myself....

Not unless it's something you eat. They're pretty good at that.

_________________
Chuck Baird
"I understand with a sigh and a duh"
-- Smiley
http://www.cbaird.org
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
bobgardner
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 12:28 AM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Sep 04, 2002
Posts: 23495
Location: Orlando Florida

Well, if it puts out 6 times as much as you put in, it should help you reduce your cooking expense, heating expense, water heating expense.

_________________
Imagecraft compiler user
 
 View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
gchapman
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 03:34 AM
Raving lunatic


Joined: Jan 09, 2007
Posts: 2577
Location: Arlington, Texas, U.S.A.

Think larger.
http://www.teslasociety.com/biography.htm, Wardenclyffe tower.
 
 View user's profile Send private message  
Reply with quote Back to top
microcarl
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 04:19 AM
Raving lunatic


Joined: May 30, 2004
Posts: 8502
Location: Cincinnati, Ohio

js wrote:
Wouldn't trust Italians myself....


Now, John, you are Italian and you are trustworthy! Laughing

_________________
Carl W. Livingston, KC5OTL
microcarl@roadrunner.com

"There are only two ways to sleep well at night... be ignorant or be prepared."

The original Dragon Slayer !

Long live the AVR!!!
 
 View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail  
Reply with quote Back to top
JohanEkdahl
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 06:01 AM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Mar 27, 2002
Posts: 21412
Location: Lund, Sweden

This is regularly reported about in the specialist tabloid for Swedish Engineers.

The scientific problem here is that "secret catalyst". A proper science report describes in detail how the experiment was done, to the point where other scientists can repeat the experiment and verify the results.

So, going meta-meta and use a physics analogy on this physics problem: Until they open that box for all to see we can not tell if the cat is alive or dead (i.e. it is snake oil or not). (Yes, I know I am abusing the original analogy...)
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
LDEVRIES
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 06:34 AM
Raving lunatic


Joined: May 04, 2007
Posts: 3738
Location: Geelong Australia, Home of the "Cats"

OK Bob, I will declare myself as a skeptic! However I just want to clear a couple of issues. In your first post you say
Quote:
He has some hydrogen

100mL, 1L, 100L,10KL ???
Quote:
and he heats it up with a KW or so,

You don't say for how long and the "or so" could be 3 or 4 or even 10 KW for an hour Ie. 10KWH
We need KWH IN & KWH out!

Quote:
Well, if it puts out 6 times as much as you put in, it should help you reduce your cooking expense, heating expense, water heating expense.

Where did the figure of 6 times come from.

Quote:
keeps putting out a couple KW

Radiated heat or electrical energy? DC or AC?

Assuming it is an exothermic reaction of the chemicals, more energy needed to have gone into the reaction then comes out.
Any thermite will produce lots & lots of heat!

Quote:
It sure would shake up the balance of cash flow from North America to North Africa.

Does the US get it's majority of oil from Libya?

You are right the "material under discussion" would seem suitable, but I could be accused of turning a 12 yo into a skeptic and destroy their creative/inquiring mind.

_________________
Charles Darwin, Lord Kelvin & Murphy are always lurking about!
Lee -.-
Riddle me this...How did the serpent move around before the fall?


Last edited by LDEVRIES on Feb 20, 2012 - 06:46 AM; edited 1 time in total
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
jan_dc
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 06:39 AM
Hangaround


Joined: Feb 09, 2011
Posts: 346
Location: Turnhout, Belgium

It exists for quite some time now. So I have one simple question: why is not commercially available?

And please do not be too naive when you try to answer this question.
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
JohanEkdahl
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 07:35 AM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Mar 27, 2002
Posts: 21412
Location: Lund, Sweden

Quote:
It exists for quite some time now.

It might, or it might not. As I noted above, there has been no independent proof of the results. AFAIK it is only Andrea Rossi's word so far.
Quote:
And please do not be too naive when you try to answer this question.

I would say that believing w/o any substantial proof is naive.

More here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
LDEVRIES
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 07:38 AM
Raving lunatic


Joined: May 04, 2007
Posts: 3738
Location: Geelong Australia, Home of the "Cats"

I thought after my initial missive, I thought I better Google Andrea Rossi's E-CAT. Well, my suspicions were pretty well confirmed I believe, he is just a flim-flam man!
I note that a well respected businessman in Australia, fas wagered him a $1,000,000 to demonstrate a working model, which Rossi cleverly declined!

_________________
Charles Darwin, Lord Kelvin & Murphy are always lurking about!
Lee -.-
Riddle me this...How did the serpent move around before the fall?
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
js
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 07:50 AM
10k+ Postman


Joined: Mar 28, 2001
Posts: 22243
Location: Sydney, Australia (Gum trees, Koalas and Kangaroos, No Edelweiss)

I have heard from someone else that some Australians are also working on the same thing.

Of course anyone having some knowledge of this may just disappear into thin air so we all better play safe and claim "ve know nuthing, nuthing,nuthing!".

_________________
John Samperi
Ampertronics Pty. Ltd.
www.ampertronics.com.au
* Electronic Design * Custom Products * Contract Assembly
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
mnehpets
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 10:42 AM
Resident


Joined: Nov 09, 2011
Posts: 592


This is a good time to review the cold fusion claims from Stanley Pons and Martin Fleischmann. Here's a relatively neutral article from a couple of years ago:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/7959183.stm

The history of Rossi's claim seems to be following a similar path. Have we learned nothing in 20 years?

js wrote:

I have heard from someone else that some Australians are also working on the same thing.


Was it from some dude called "Aussie Guy E-Cat"? He claims to have replicated Pons & Fleischmann, which makes me very suspicious.

- S
 
 View user's profile Send private message  
Reply with quote Back to top
Torby
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 03:11 PM
Raving lunatic


Joined: Nov 11, 2003
Posts: 5801
Location: Broken Arrow OK USA

Yup! We've learned that we don't learn anything from experience.

Also, history is full of valid claims being thought flim-flam, and the other way 'round.

_________________
Torby

You can't always believe everything you think.
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
LDEVRIES
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 09:12 PM
Raving lunatic


Joined: May 04, 2007
Posts: 3738
Location: Geelong Australia, Home of the "Cats"

On one video, Rossi shows some steam coming out of a rubber hose that he says is produced by "the reaction". It did require about 740 watts of heat to produce it though. My electric jug will produce more steam than that, without any of the hocus- pocus.
Of course if his system produced energy than you put in , it should be a self-sustaining reaction, which he says can't be done because of stability issues. Snake oil!

_________________
Charles Darwin, Lord Kelvin & Murphy are always lurking about!
Lee -.-
Riddle me this...How did the serpent move around before the fall?
 
 View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
abcminiuser
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 09:53 PM
Moderator


Joined: Jan 23, 2004
Posts: 10204
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Absolutely - time and time again, all these "magic" energy sources always require some sort of external power to work, be it a battery, mains power or something else. If something really is putting out more energy than you put in, you should be able to power it from itself.

While I do believe we have yet to unlock some secrets of the universe, I doubt some guys "secret magic sauce" will be it. This is the Steorn Orbo all over again.

- Dean Twisted Evil

_________________
Make Atmel Studio better with my free extensions. Open source and feedback welcome!
 
 View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website 
Reply with quote Back to top
peret
PostPosted: Feb 20, 2012 - 09:57 PM
Raving lunatic


Joined: May 26, 2004
Posts: 2542
Location: Las Vegas, Nevada

It's routine to get kilowatt-hours of power out of chemical reactions. We generally call such reactors "batteries" or "furnaces". If the experimenter puts "a kW or so" into the mass for an hour, and it doesn't liquify and burn through the floor, there must be a substantial quantity of nickel available to react. One must offset one's expectations of reduced cooking and heating costs against the cost of substantial quantities of pure nickel, which is undoubtedly consumed in the reaction. As for the copper, Occam's Razor suggests that contamination or sloppy experimental procedures are more likely than nuclear transmutation.
 
 View user's profile Send private message  
Reply with quote Back to top
westfw
PostPosted: Feb 21, 2012 - 01:45 AM
Posting Freak


Joined: Jun 19, 2002
Posts: 1332
Location: SF Bay area

Quote:
why is not commercially available?

or if you believe in massive conspiracies, why hasn't the Italian government stolen the secret sauce and used it to solve their country's finance problems?

Quote:
some Australians are also working on the same thing.

Scamming people? No doubt!
 
 View user's profile Send private message  
Reply with quote Back to top
Display posts from previous:     
Jump to:  
All times are GMT + 1 Hour
Post new topic   Reply to topic
View previous topic Printable version Log in to check your private messages View next topic
Powered by PNphpBB2 © 2003-2006 The PNphpBB Group
Credits